Friday, May 30, 2008

On the Richmond young adult Friends conference

For those of you for whom an super-Quaker post is surprising or not very interesting, be forewarned: this is about to get very Quaker.

About a hundred young adult Friends gathered last weekend at the Earlham School of Religion (a Quaker seminary) in Richmond, Indiana for a conference titled Living as Friends, Listening Within. The theme was leadings and callings (discerning vocation and/or God's will for you) and the conference intentionally brought together Friends from across the branches of Quakerism, including independent western Friends, Conservative Friends, and Friends from meetings affiliated with Friends United Meeting, Friends General Conference, Evangelical Friends International. The conference was sponsored by FUM, FGC and Philadelphia Yearly Meeting (For those of you wanting to know more about the branches, go here.)

The balancing of these two goals -- exploring leadings and callings, and fostering ecumenical fellowship among Friends -- was delicate and faithful and interesting to watch. The two goals often, but not always, functioned in tandem (sometimes quite well). In some ways the combination was very appropriate -- many Friends are feeling called to heal the divisions in Quakerism, though there are several ideas of what that means. Sometimes one or the other of the conference goals would take precedence. Even if we weren't working with it explicitly, it seemed like we were always aware of our diversity, of the relative unusualness of our gathering together.

Overall, it was a really beautiful weekend. The care, respect, tenderness and love the planning committee of young adult Friends have for each other was abundantly evident, and it set the tone for the weekend. The conference was well organized, responsibility and visibility was well shared, and several onion layers of support people (including a pastoral care team) were available, accessible and well used. There were lots of resources on Friends events, organizations, publications and communities. (I and some of the other editorial board members who were there talked about the Quaker Youth Book Project and distributed the Call for Submissions.)

You can read the epistle (a letter from a gathered body of Friends to Friends everywhere) to get a deeper idea of what the weekend was like.

Throughout the weekend two images were working on me, both having to do with ecumenical work among Friends. The first was this sense that I had finally waded deep enough into the water, far enough from my comfort zone of the shore, to find a deep, cool, gentle and tantalizing current of movement among Friends. I've had a sense of this current for awhile, I sort of knew it was there, but this weekend I finally went deep enough to feel it working on me and pulling me to new places. I don't know where it's taking me, but when I couldn't feel the bottom anymore I looked up to find I wasn't alone. Many other Friends, many of them young adults, are moving in the current too. This was really exciting and humbling.

The other image is not as positive. During several intense meetings for worship, which were often punctuated by song and by weeping -- and were quite moving -- I kept getting the sense that we were wanting to eat the fruit of Friends unity (or the bread, pick your metaphor ) without doing the careful work of cultivation.

The story of the Little Red Hen ("Will you help me grind my grain??") kept popping into my head, but also those Bible verses about being the branches and bearing fruit, and sitting under the vine and fig tree and being unafraid. Those are all plants that you cultivate. God is a gardener, and I think he calls us to that kind of intentional cultivation in partnership that good gardeners and farmers practice.

There are difficult conversations to be had, and we only brushed the surface this weekend because it's hard to do a lot in a weekend. Those conversations are about theology, God and Jesus, sexuality, queerness, racial diversity, welcoming and affirmation, continuing revelation and the Bible, our common history as Friends, the divisions in our history, and the myriad ways we have wounded one another.

At the risk of sounding like a naysayer (which I am not), I think intensely emotional meetings for worship, and songs about rising up to take our places, are not the work or are not all of the work of cultivating unity among Friends. They feed us and inspire us for the work, but they are not the entirety of the work and are not grounds for self-congratulation.

I think my fear -- and it's a fear, so I'll name it as that -- is that Friends will come away from this weekend high on ecumenical fellowship and not do anything, not let their experiences work on and transform them. That is not enough.

This is what I know. When you love someone or someones -- a partner, your family, a community, an organization -- there has to be a willingness to do the hard work. The first step is to know one another, which I think these conferences (at Richmond and Burlington, NJ last year) and other events and inter visitation of similar flavor, accomplish. They are just the beginning, and I am so grateful to Friends who open that door.

But then you do the hard work. In my opinion, the start of the hard work is to speak our own truths, and listen - listen - to others speak theirs. Friends, I think we're ready to do the hard work.

And in so many ways it is already being done. Models exist for us to look to: FWCC , the World Gathering, QUIP, convergent Friends, Quaker bloggers, Friends doing yearly meeting inter visitation, etc. etc.

And maybe after listening we will all go home to our individual meetings and churches and there will be renewal and deepening within the branches. Or maybe nothing will happen. Or maybe there will be increased communication and growth between the branches. Or perhaps whole new meetings and churches will emerge, and national and international bodies of Friends will be transformed and reorganized. I am so excited to tell cranky unprogrammed Friends (who say things like "I just don't know about those pastoral Friends....") about my friends from FUM and EFI meetings and churches and see their jaws drop.

Who knows what will happen. But we have to do the hard work first. And then we have to call others to the hard work.

When my own yearly meeting reunified in the 1950's, it was the young people (along with some supportive older folks) who lead it. They gathered together for years beforehand -- dated each other, married each other -- and when they gathered they often wore red or white roses to identify them as Hicksite or Orthodox. It was a way of saying "This is my tradition, in case you were wondering. Now let's meet as Friends."

Friends, where is your roses?

Something I have been working under and striving to articulate is a sense I have of the diversity of Friends as an incredible blessing, an incredible gift to us. The diversity of Christians (not to mention the diversity of the world at large) is so vast, some of the differences seemingly so deep -- I am so keenly aware of living in a deeply fractured and disconnected world -- and here we have the opportunity to hone tools of fellowship, communication, listening, and love in our own house.

Several of the keynote speakers reminded us that the world needs us, as Friends, that our message of an immanent God is powerful and transformative despite our small numbers.

More and more I believe that our diversity -- our theological, racial, geographic, gender identifying and sexual diversity - is one way that God prepares us for that work in the world.

7 comments:

Robin M. said...

It always worries me that Friends get together and think it's so wonderful, and it is, but then it's so hard when we get home and the ordinary people in our home meetings and churches are just that, so ordinary and frustrating.

How can we learn in our gatherings how to do the hard work of being present in the mundane and sometimes trivial work of being a regular part of a monthly meeting? How can we expect to be taken seriously if we're not willing to shoulder the ordinary responsibilities as well as the burdens of new leadings?

Can we learn about raising these questions in an environment that isn't full of people that already agree with us and where so many people seem more interested in the boring stuff than in the fiery ministry we just heard last weekend? Can we see that under some grey heads are people who are also waiting for something more exciting to come along?

Just wondering. I'm glad it was a good meeting and I look forward to hearing more from Friends who were there over the course of this summer and the coming years.

Keefe-Perry Commons said...

"I think my fear -- and it's a fear, so I'll name it as that -- is that Friends will come away from this weekend high on ecumenical fellowship and not do anything, not let their experiences work on and transform them. That is not enough."

You fully speak my mind. I pray that Friends heard the weekend as a call to connect to the Other and do the deep work needed to allow the soil to hold the roots tight. It is the conversion of manners and the joy and challenge of true fellowship in work/service that must come before the harvest.

Many thanks for this posting, it clarified some thoughts for me.

-Callid

Micah Bales said...

Thank you for this post, Angelina. I think you hit the nail on the head. This gathering has to be a springboard for greater dedication and faithfulness, not just a "high." One query that I would pose for those of us who carry this concern:

How do I empower other Friends to live into God's call for them?

Tom and Sandy Farley said...

Quick storytelling note from Tom:
You have mixed Chicken Little [and friend Henny Penny] “The sky is falling.” with Little Red Hen “Who will help me…then I’ll do it myself.” Both are tales with long histories as social/political allegory. There is an old socialist song ending with “that’s why they call her Red.”

Recently there was a discussion on the Storytell e-mail list of the message of LRH and ethics issues around changing the story to change the message.

PamelaDraper said...

Angelina - thank you for your thoughts about the conference. It makes me wish (even more than I already had) that I could have attended! ;) I agree completely with your perspective on the Quaker landscape and what is needed.

I am still discouraged, however. Just as the sentiment "Let there be peace on earth, and let it begin with me," implies, this hard work we speak of must begin in our own meeting communities, our own spiritual circles. Petty grudges, hidden hurts, personal prejudices: I have witnessed too many hurts and not enough healing and forgiveness. I have brought hard work to the table and been turned down more than once. I'm lacking faith, therefore, in our ability as Friends to do this work on a larger scale. Perhaps I cannot see the forest for the trees.

It is comforting to know that you and other young adult friends feel as I do. I pray that we keep in mind all the ways that we are called to do hard work with each other and for the strength that this work requires.

Angelina said...

Thanks all.

I really hear the concern about doing work internally, in Friends meetings and churches, as well as externally. Maintaining and sustaining the work is another question, too.

@ Tom - thanks for catching that error! I changed it to Little Red Hen.

Liz Opp said...

OMG, Angelina.

I am having one of those moments where, when you're deep in worship and you've just had A Thought, and you're mulling it over and you know in a deep place that it's Important...

...and then someone stands up and says PRECISELY what you were thinking.

Last week, I thought through the tale and message of Little Red Hen, just as you have written it here. And it is So Important that I see my very thought coming off the page that you've created, lest I completely forget about having thought it myself...

In addition, like you and others who have commented here, I have been carrying a concern for doing the work of cultivating the soil and not focusing on planting the seed. The soil must be prepared so that the seed has a better chance of taking root when it actually is planted!

For the sake of being transparent, I'll add that I'm 45 and therefore removed from participating in certain opportunities with fired-up young adult Friends. ...I'd love to have a fishbowl of YAFs and OAFs (older adult Friends) to learn more about who we are, what we wrestle with, etc etc.

The last thing I wanted to say right now is I no longer think of cultivation as "hard" work. I think of it as slow work.

For me, the work has included building relationships; serving on committees so I can learn how they might be interconnected; getting refreshment and inspiration from retreats and workshops; maintaining communication with Friends who "get me" but who aren't part of my meeting; requesting a committee to help me test my impulse to challenge, confront, call out the (failings) of the meeting; take seriously those "chance" opportunities to have a conversation with a newcomer, with a somewhat new attender; attend Quakerism 101 sessions in case a different perspective or understanding might be of help...

It's not that I think about doing any of these things; it's just that these are things that I've ended up doing over the years... like connecting the dots and not knowing what picture was going to emerge until many dots later.

In this way, the work of cultivating the soil is not only hard and slow, it's also often very subtle. Folks won't necessarily know that something's different or who has been working "under the radar," but then again, "by the fruits shall you know them."

Thanks again for sharing your experience so openly. It's given me a needed pause just now...

Blessings,
Liz Opp, The Good Raised Up